Citation with stable link: Philip A. Harland, 'Celts and Germans: Galen, Julian, and others on putting babies in the cold water of the Rhine (first century BCE on),' Ethnic Relations and Migration in the Ancient World, last modified November 16, 2026, https://philipharland.com/Blog/?p=17619.
Ancient authors: Anonymous author preserved in Palatine anthology (likely after the mid-first century BCE), Greek Anthology 9.125 (link); Galen (mid-late second century CE), Discourses on Health / De sanitate tuenda (link; link to Greek); Julian, The Heroic Deeds of the Emperor Constantius, or, On Kingship 2.81-82 (link); Libanius, Prosgymnasmata, Exercize in Narration 37, On the Rhine) (fourth century CE) (link to Greek).
Comments: Numerous authors writing in Greek make the claim that Celts (or Germans, a new term for certain Celts to the northeast, introduced by Caesar or a contemporary – link) had the custom of placing newborn babies into the cold water of the Rhine river. This is usually explained as a test regarding whether or not the child was legitimate and, if the child was not, they would not be returned. As Antti Lampinen’s (2014) article on the subject clarifies, there is absolutely no evidence that this was an actual practice and we can attribute this stereotype to the creativity of authors imagining resilient, daring or bold northerners.
Works consulted: A. Lampinen, “Cruel and Unusual? The Idea of ‘Celtic’ Justice in Greek Novelistic Writing,” Studia Celtica Fennica 11 (2014): 8–23 (link).
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
Anonymous author (50s BCE or after, when the designation the “Rhine” was adopted)
(Greek Anthology 9.125) The daring (tharsaleoi) Celts (Keltoi) test their children in the jealous Rhine (Rhenos), and none regards himself as being the child’s father until he sees it washed by that venerated water. At once, when the baby has glided from its mother’s lap and sheds its first tears, the father himself lifts it up and places it on his shield, not caring at all for its suffering. For he does not feel for it like a father until he sees it judged by the bath in the river, the test of conjugal fidelity. The mother, suffering new pangs added to those of childbirth, even though she knows him to be the child’s true father, awaits in fear and trembling the pronouncement of the unstable stream.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
Galen (mid-late second century CE)
(Discourses on Health 1.10) Among the Germans (Germanoi), children are not raised properly. But we are not now writing this for the Germans or for any other savage (agrioi) or barbarian (barbaroi) people, any more than for bears, boars, lions, or for any of the other wild beasts (thēria). Rather, we are writing this for Greeks and for those who, though born barbarians by nature, still emulate (zēlousi) the ways of the Greeks. For who among us, or among people who live among us, would tolerate that a newborn infant, still warm from the womb, should be taken to the waters of the rivers and there, as the Germans say, at the same time to test their nature and toughen their bodies by dipping them into the cold water like white-hot iron?
For if the babies endure this without harm, it is clear to everyone that they show strength of intrinsic nature and acquire more from contact with the cold. And likewise no one ignores that, if a child’s natural warmth is overcome by the external cold, it is inevitable that he should immediately die. Who, therefore, in his right mind and not completely savage or barbaric, would choose to put his own child to such a test, in which there is an unlikely possibility of death, and when he is not going to gain much from the danger? Perhaps it would be worthwhile for a donkey or some other dumb animal to have a hide so thick and tough as to bear the cold without pain. But for man, a rational animal, what great advantage would it be? For no one would say that the thickest and toughest skin is necessarily advantageous for health, so to speak. For since there may be twofold injury to the bodies of animals, one from external and the other from internal causes, those are more susceptible to all external lesions whose skin is thin and soft, and those to internal lesions whose skin is thick and tough.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
Julian (360s CE)
(The Heroic Deeds of the Emperor Constantius, or, On Kingship 2.81-82; cf. Libanius, Orations 12.48). . . For just as a noble birth is better than a lowly pedigree, so virtue is better than a character not in all respects admirable. And let no one say that this statement is contentious and too strong, judging by the ordinary use of words. For the common people are used to saying that the sons of those who have long been rich are well-born. And yet is it not extraordinary that a cook or cobbler, yes, by Zeus, or some potter who has got money together by his craft, or by some other means, is not considered well-born nor is given that title by the many. Whereas, if this man’s son inherits his estate and hands it on to his sons, they begin to give themselves airs and compete on the score of noble birth with the Pelopids and the Heraclids? No, even a man who is born of noble ancestors, but himself sinks down in the opposite scale of life, could not justly claim kinship with those ancestors, seeing that no one could be enrolled among the Pelopids who had not on his shoulder the birth-mark of that family.
Furthermoree, in Boiotia it was said that there was the impression of a spear on the Sown-men (Spartoi) from the clod of earth that bore and raised them, and that this descent group (genos) long preserved that distinguishing mark. Can we suppose that on men’s souls there is no mark of that sort engraved, a mark which would tell us accurately who their fathers were and vindicate their birth as legitimate?
They say that the Celts (Keltoi) also have a river which is an impartial judge of the legitimacy of offspring, and neither can the mothers persuade that river by their laments to hide and conceal their fault [i.e. adultery] for them, nor can the fathers who are afraid for their wives and sons in this trial, but it is an arbiter that never swerves or gives a false verdict. But we are corrupted by riches, by physical strength in its prime, by powerful ancestors, an influence from without that overshadows and does not permit us to see clearly or discern the soul. For we are unlike all other living things in this, that by the soul and by nothing else, we should with reason make our decision about noble birth. . . [remainder of Oration omitted].
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
Libanius
(Prosgymnasmata, Exercize in Narration 37, On the Rhine) The Rhine, the barbarian river, being a judge of self-control, flows through the land of the Celts. For whenever a child has just been born to them, they take it and put it beside the river’s edge. But he [the river], receiving them, gives the legitimate ones back to their parents, but kills the illegitimate ones by pouring out over his banks. And he passes judgment on their self-control with both life and death.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
Source of translations: W. R. Paton, The Greek Anthology, 5 vols. (HUP, 1917); R.M. Green (d. 1955), A Translation of Galen’s Hygiene (De Sanitate Tuenda) (Charles Thomas, 1951); Wilmer Cave France Wright, The Works of the Emperor Julian, 3 vols., LCL (HUP, 1913), public domain, modified by Harland. Craig A. Gibson, Libanius’s Progymnasmata: Model Exercises in Greek Prose Composition and Rhetoric (SBL Press, 2008), adapted by Harland under educational fair use provisions.
